Tuesday, April 22, 2008

The Failure of "Expelled"

It looks as if the movie "Expelled" has been a complete failure. Rather than the $15 million that the producers were hoping to acquire on opening week, the movie made less than $3 million. I do not know what the expenses were for this movie, but I think that there is a good chance that it will have been a net loss for those involved. In the mean time, the Truth Tickets counter campaign must have been a net benefit for the National Center for Science Education, since the donations came with no expense on their part.

In addition, the movie provided me with a benefit that I certainly value. Spending 8 months as a first-page hit for those doing Google and Yahoo internet searches for the movie meant a lot of visitors to my blog that I would have otherwise had. Some of them became regular subscribers. The movie brought me - and continues to bring me - a level of exposure greater than the combined value of all of my other work.

And I would like to think that this first-page hit for the past 8 months, immediately available for those looking for information on the movie - is at least partially responsible for the movie's failure. If this is true, then I would conclude that I had made an important contribution to making the world a better place than it would have otherwise been.

Even though my efforts here are negative efforts - an effort that does not actually count as 'promoting good', but as 'avoiding harm'.

I would like readers to reflect for a moment, that a significant portion of the failure of Ben Stein's movie can be traced to getting Christians to reject Stein's message. A lot of Christians rejected a group of their own. If they had not done so, then this piece of hate-mongering propaganda would have been a success.

Just a thought.

2 comments:

Greg said...

I wouldn't exactly say we rejected our own...more that we know propaganda when we see it, regardless of who produces it.

I'm a theistic evolutionist, so I've got no love for the ID movement. Theres a fun discussion going on about the movie's topic over here if you'd like some Christian perspective on it.

http://www.reclaimingthemind.org/blog/2008/04/21/expelled-evolution-vs-intelligent-design-a-review/

Greg

Alonzo Fyfe said...

I would not say that these options are incompatible. You rejected one of your own because you recognize propaganda when you see it. My point being that a success of this requires the cooperation of theists with integrity who will reject propaganda when they see it.